When Jailers Kill People in Custody, Few Face Criminal Charges
Michael Burch moved to rural Colorado for a quiet retirement looking after his horses.
He was writing a memoir about his career as a correctional officer when he began battling memory loss and age-related decline. A mental health crisis struck, and complaints about his erratic behavior landed the 69-year-old in the Huerfano County Detention Center.
Burch didn’t follow orders when guards demanded he return a pencil. Video shows two officers confronting him in his cell. “Drop it or we’ll drop you,” one warns just before Burch was shocked with a Taser and slammed into a metal bench.
“Right side is crushed,” he tells paramedics. “All the ribs are into my body.”
In the days that followed, Burch banged on his cell door and screamed for help. His pleas for medical care for his shattered ribs were ignored. A week later, Burch prepared his own deathbed, putting his mattress on the floor and pulling a sheet over his body, a family lawyer said.
He was pronounced dead the following morning on April 4, 2023.
What happened next has played out time and again across the country: Burch’s death was ruled a homicide by the county coroner, but the jail staff who killed him were not charged with — let alone convicted of — a crime.
Bloomberg Law identified 71 people who were beaten, suffocated, neglected or restrained by jail staff in the past ten years and whose deaths were ruled homicides by a government pathologist. Only 27% of those deaths led to criminal charges against detention officers. So far, only three have led to jail staff serving time in prison.
A man arrested for driving with a suspended license was punched to death by guards in a South Florida jail, according to a civil rights lawsuit. A San Diego jail tactical team shot a man arrested for intoxication with water balls and a shock gun, an autopsy report stated, then smothered him under a body shield. North of Dallas, detention officers strapped a man with schizophrenia to a restraint bed, pepper sprayed him, and suffocated him, according to a state death report and a lawyer representing his parents. He’d been arrested on a misdemeanor marijuana charge.
Though jail employees’ actions contributed to each of these deaths, no one was ever charged.
Use-of-force experts say the lack of accountability that starts with a culture of violence between inmates and guards is tolerated in US jails and complicated by a lack of mental health services inside and outside of those facilities. When violence by guards turns fatal, investigators and prosecutors often defer to the judgment of jail guards and find that there wasn’t enough evidence to convict them of a crime, according to five law professors and former law enforcement officials.
Prosecutors, investigators, and grand juries decided not to pursue criminal charges in most of the 71 cases, often saying they could not prove guards’ actions were unlawful. Sometimes they gave no reason for their decision. Prosecutors may decline cases over doubts about the evidence, as ethical standards advise a reasonable belief they can prove someone’s guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.
“The idea that criminal charges are pursued on very few, that raises the question as to whether or not they’re being properly investigated,” said US Rep. Bobby Scott, D-Va., who has been trying for decades to get the Justice Department to accurately track deaths in custody. “A human being should not die unnecessarily.”
Several guards who were charged and convicted were sentenced only to probation. Others pleaded guilty and received deferred adjudication, which allows them to avoid prison and a criminal conviction if they complete probation. One death in Wisconsin led to short jail sentences, the longest of which was nine months.
Bloomberg Law analyzed in-custody death investigations, autopsy reports and thousands of court documents to identify homicides linked to jail staff. Since most states don’t publish reports, and not everyone has relatives who can or do sue, the homicides identified are likely an undercount. Civil rights lawyers have also questioned cases in which examiners ruled deaths as natural or undetermined despite evidence of detention officers’ involvement.
Burch’s autopsy report showed six fractured ribs, internal bleeding and a collapsed lung, and listed the cause of his death as complications from blunt force trauma to the chest and abdomen. Coroner Dr. Leon Kelly wrote that the injuries happened when he was shocked with a Taser and wrestled to the ground by law enforcement.
Agents from the Colorado Bureau of Investigation handled Burch’s homicide investigation. They shared their findings with the local district attorney, who declined to bring any criminal charges against the officers, according to a letter sent to the lead investigator.
Huerfano County officials declined to comment through an attorney, other than to note that one of the jailers no longer works there. The Third Judicial District Attorney’s Office declined a request for comment.
There’s an assumption that those who die in custody somehow deserve their fate, said Omeed Azmoudeh, who represented Burch’s family in a civil rights lawsuit.
“This is one of your own people,” Azmoudeh said. “He showed the same compassion that you all should have shown.”
How Burch Died
The video below contains graphic content. It shows the last days of Michael Burch’s life in the custody of the Huerfano County Jail, from March 28 to April 4, 2023. His death was ruled a homicide, but no one was charged with a crime. Details in the timeline are from the Colorado Bureau of Investigation’s report on Burch’s death. The video was provided by the attorneys for Burch’s family.
Read the article in its entirety here.
