Skip to content

Can a 72-year-old protect herself at work? Colorado’s high court says yes

Workers at Colorado businesses have the right to defend themselves against unprovoked workplace violence, the Colorado Supreme Court said on Monday.

Mary Ann Moreno, then 72, had been working as a Circle K store clerk for 16 years when a man came into the store in October 2020 and was acting erratically. He got close to her behind the counter and had two knives, according to court records. She pushed him before he eventually stole some cigarettes, the records say. The next day, Circle K fired her, saying she instigated the scuffle.

Moreno got an attorney and sued.

“This was obviously a devastating experience for her. She had this low-wage work and she dedicated herself for 16 years to this company and the next day they just fired her after this traumatizing experience for her,” said her attorney, Iris Halpern. “There was zero sympathy.”

The legal battle centers on whether Colorado workers have the right to self-defense in the workplace, whether that is a public right, rather than an individual proprietary one, and whether that right is at all work-related, given workplaces can be places of violence.

The state’s high court said in an opinion on Monday that people do have a right to challenge their terminations for actions taken in self-defense. The case will now return to federal district court.

In briefs filed in the case, Halpern argued that workplaces are increasingly places of violence and that robberies happen regularly at convenience stores. She also pointed out in briefs that two recent mass shootings, one at a Boulder King Soopers store in 2021 and a 2022 shooting at a Colorado Springs nightclub both happened at workplaces.

On Monday, Halpern said Colorado was the third state in the country to recognize self-defense as an individual right, which allows people to challenge terminations based on it. She said it affects workers statewide “immediately.”

“There is an objective test here. Did you objectively have reason to fear that you were going to be injured or killed?” she said. “It’s a huge right. Employees shouldn’t have to give up their rights to defend their lives and the lives of others on the job.”

The Supreme Court’s opinion is the latest twist in an unusual case that has worked its way through both federal and state courts. Two years ago, it seemed Moreno had lost any chance of winning her suit when a federal judge dismissed it because she “wasn’t in position to recognize, in the first instance, a new type of public policy exception to Colorado’s at-will employment doctrine.”

That decision was reviewed and rejected by the federal 10th Circuit Court of Appeals, prompting the judge to then ask the Colorado Supreme Court to offer their opinion on whether Colorado law protects Moreno from termination. They did.

It doesn’t mean she has won her suit, but for now, it is alive and back in federal court.

Denver lawyers representing Circle K did not immediately respond to a request for comment on behalf of their client.

Read the article in its entirety here.